I would like to return to our discussion on Wednesday about
iPod Culture. Almost everybody mentioned ways that using iPods have changed our behavior. I think that this has strong parallels with
Technological Determinism. Potts says, "as media technologies change, profound cultural effects ensue. These effects operate on both the level of the individual psyche and the social formation as a whole." Our discussion was largely centered around this idea as it relates to iPods. We automatically recognize that someone with both earbuds in should be left alone, that it is common courtesy to take on bud out when you talk to someone else, and we do not talk to each other on the bus anymore. These examples of our cultural norms that have changed from iPod use, suggest that some technological changes are powerful enough to be more than one more element within a larger social movement. The technology itself is the catalyst of this social movement by tapping into parts of our psyche that previously went ignored. In the case of iPod, I am concerned that this technology may have a dehumanizing effect. Instead of socializing with people around us, we dwell in the isolation of iPod music. We are using the iPod like a drug o escape from the pressures of big cities and crowded buses, and we become dependent on it for constant stimulation and when forced to cope without it we have lost the ability to reintegrate into the society.
I agree with you Aaron. I think that the iPod is taking away a crucial part of human interaction....the unknown conversations and interactions. With earbuds in, and paying no attention to the world around us, we are lacking the training of our brain/mind to be able to communicate properly and deal with situations. Instead of coping with the crowded bus, loud noises, or people who want to talk to us, we are shutting down and ignoring them. Im not saying it's good or bad. Don't get me wrong. Im just saying that I agree that it is definitely changing things on a different level in our society than what most people are seeing.
ReplyDeleteI also agree that technologies such as the ipod have become an integral part of our ever changing culture. However, as we mentioned in class, technology may not be the cause of this. I agree that it helps this behavior, but I also think that some people would act that way with or without the technology.
ReplyDeleteI do believe that the ipod is part of what has changed the way we communicate with others. However, I think the difficultly comes when looking at communication between different generations. For example, it is way easier to have a conversation through texting with someone your own age than it is with your mom. (Well, at least for me it is.) We tend to think of older people as less technologically advanced, which I believe is where a lot of the communication issues start.
I disagree with the idea that iPods are taking away from people being good communicators. While it's true that some people don't interact as much as a result of the iPod, communication and public relations can be learned through so many facets of our life, not just the commute to a from classes. Communication develops in the classroom, at a job, or when going out. People don't bring their iPods to bars or house parties because they are going to be crowded public places.
ReplyDeleteI think that it is important to note that the iPod is not the only technological device being used to escape from public areas. Other MP3 players, PSPs and cell phones are also to blame. In general I don’t think that iPods are having that big of an effect on people’s social skills. It’s not the iPod that causes strangers to ignore each other (although it helps). Before the invention of the iPod, I rarely ever witnessed strangers having conversations with each other. I think people are naturally hesitant to communicate with others that they don’t know.
ReplyDelete